| Year | Voted By | Ballots | Votes Needed | Total Votes | Vote % = Total Votes÷Votes Needed | Inducted | Inducted For | | 1964 | Run Off | 201 | 0 | 8 | % | No | Player | | 1964 | BBWAA | 201 | 151 | 33 | % | No | Player | | 1966 | BBWAA | 302 | 227 | 29 | % | No | Player | | 1967 | Run Off | 306 | 0 | 11 | % | No | Player | | 1967 | BBWAA | 292 | 219 | 40 | % | No | Player | | 1968 | BBWAA | 283 | 213 | 47 | % | No | Player | | 1969 | BBWAA | 340 | 255 | 60 | % | No | Player | | 1970 | BBWAA | 300 | 225 | 90 | % | No | Player | | 1971 | BBWAA | 360 | 270 | 105 | % | No | Player | | 1972 | BBWAA | 396 | 297 | 115 | % | No | Player | | 1973 | BBWAA | 380 | 285 | 114 | % | No | Player | | 1974 | BBWAA | 365 | 274 | 94 | % | No | Player | | 1975 | BBWAA | 362 | 272 | 114 | % | No | Player | | 1976 | BBWAA | 388 | 291 | 129 | % | No | Player | | 1977 | BBWAA | 383 | 288 | 141 | % | No | Player | | 1983 | Veterans | 0 | 0 | 0 | % | Yes | Player |
|
| The Daily Diamond