| Player | Salary | | Joe Ausanio | $110,000 | | Scott Bankhead | $500,000 | | Brian Boehringer | $109,000 | | Wade Boggs | $4,724,316 | | Russ Davis | $109,000 | | Kevin Elster | $300,000 | | Tony Fernandez | $1,633,335 | | Greg Harris | $200,000 | | Sterling Hitchcock | $125,000 | | Steve Howe | $2,300,000 | | Dion James | $350,000 | | Scott Kamieniecki | $1,100,000 | | Pat Kelly | $1,085,000 | | Jimmy Key | $4,873,700 | | Jim Leyritz | $1,350,000 | | Bob Macdonald | $260,000 | | Josias Manzanillo | $175,000 | | Don Mattingly | $4,420,000 | | Jack McDowell | $5,400,000 | | Paul O'Neill | $2,850,000 | | Dave Pavlas | $109,000 | | Melido Perez | $3,450,000 | | Andy Pettitte | $109,000 | | Luis Polonia | $1,500,000 | | Mariano Rivera | $109,000 | | Dave Silvestri | $116,000 | | Mike Stanley | $912,500 | | Darryl Strawberry | $675,000 | | Danny Tartabull | $5,300,000 | | Randy Velarde | $500,000 | | John Wetteland | $3,375,000 | | Bob Wickman | $220,000 | | Bernie Williams | $400,000 | | Gerald Williams | $125,000 | | Career | $48,874,851 |
|
| The Daily Diamond